Bank PO Mains Reasoning: Data Sufficiency, Input-Output & Critical Reasoning Made Simple

A friendly guide to three IBPS and SBI PO Mains reasoning areas, with a clear method for data sufficiency, a step-tracking routine for input-output machines and simple tests for every critical reasoning type, all with worked examples.

Reviewed by (19 years teaching)Written with AI helpReport a mistake

8 min read · Published 1 November 2026

Part of Banking (IBPS / SBI) prep

The loan officer's file check

A loan officer at a bank branch does not ask 'How much should this person get?' first. She first asks 'Do I have enough papers in this file to decide?' Salary slip alone, maybe not. Bank statement alone, maybe not. Both together, perhaps yes. Data sufficiency works the same way: you are the officer, and your job is to judge whether the information is enough, not always to work out the final answer.

What Mains reasoning is really testing

Prelims reasoning is mostly about speed. PO Mains reasoning is about judgement. Alongside long puzzles, you will usually see data sufficiency, input-output machines and critical reasoning questions. Each one has a fixed method. Once you follow the method, these become some of the steadiest marks in the section.

Data sufficiency: decide, don't over-solve

You get a question and two statements, I and II. You check whether I alone, II alone, or both together give one definite answer. On PadhoDost we use four options: I alone, II alone, both together, or neither. Real papers often add a fifth option, 'either I alone or II alone is sufficient', for when each statement works on its own.

Sufficient = you reach ONE definite answer (a single value, or a sure Yes, or a sure No). Not sufficient = two or more answers are still possible.
  1. 1Read the question and note exactly what is asked (a value, a name, or a Yes/No).
  2. 2Cover Statement II with your hand. Check Statement I alone.
  3. 3Now forget Statement I completely. Check Statement II alone.
  4. 4Only if neither works alone, combine them and check again.
  5. 5If even the combination leaves two possibilities, the answer is 'neither'.
What you foundOption to mark
I works, II does notI alone is sufficient
II works, I does notII alone is sufficient
Neither works alone, together they workBoth together are needed
Even together, two answers remainNeither is sufficient
Each works alone (5-option papers only)Either I or II alone

Worked example: who is the tallest?

Question: Among P, Q, R and S, who is the tallest?

I. P is taller than both Q and R.

II. S is shorter than Q.

I alone: P > Q and P > R, but S is unknown. S might be taller than P. Not sufficient.

II alone: S < Q tells us nothing about P or R. Not sufficient.

Together: P > Q > S and P > R. P beats all three.

Answer: both statements together are needed.

The most common mistake is letting Statement I leak into your check of Statement II. When you test II alone, pretend you never read I. If you used even one fact from I, you were really testing 'both together'.
A sure No is a complete answer. If the question is 'Is Asha older than Ravi?' and Statement I says Asha is 24 and Ravi is 29, the answer is a definite No. That makes Statement I sufficient.

Worked example: inequality DS

Question: Is X > Z definitely true?

I. X > Y ≥ Z

II. X ≥ W, W = Z

I alone: X > Y ≥ Z has one strict sign, so X > Z for sure. Sufficient.

II alone: X ≥ W = Z gives only X ≥ Z. X could equal Z. Not sufficient.

Answer: I alone is sufficient.

Quick check

Is Neha taller than Om? I. Om is 170 cm tall. II. Neha is 5 cm shorter than Om.

Input-output: watching the machine work

An input-output question shows a line of words and numbers (the input) and how a machine rearranges it, one step at a time. Your job is to spot the rule and then apply it to a new input, or answer questions about a particular step. The rule is usually a sort: words in alphabetical order, numbers in increasing or decreasing order, placed from one end.

  1. 1Look at the last step first. It shows the final pattern (for example, words A to Z on the left, numbers big to small on the right).
  2. 2Compare Input with Step I: which one or two elements moved, and to which end?
  3. 3Confirm the same rule works for Step II and Step III.
  4. 4For a new input, write the input once, then write each step on a new line below it. Never jump straight to a later step.
  5. 5Remember: elements not being placed keep their relative order.

Worked example: words left, numbers right

Rule: each step places the next word (alphabetical) from the left and the next number (increasing) from the right.

Input: 57 lotus 12 rose 88 daisy 35 iris

Words in order: daisy, iris, lotus, rose. Numbers in order: 12, 35, 57, 88.

Step I (daisy, 12): daisy 57 lotus rose 88 35 iris 12

Step II (iris, 35): daisy iris 57 lotus rose 88 35 12

Step III (lotus, 57): daisy iris lotus rose 88 57 35 12

Now rose and 88 are already in place, so Step III is the last step, even though there are four words.

StepElements placedArrangement
InputNone57 lotus 12 rose 88 daisy 35 iris
Idaisy, 12daisy 57 lotus rose 88 35 iris 12
IIiris, 35daisy iris 57 lotus rose 88 35 12
IIIlotus, 57daisy iris lotus rose 88 57 35 12
Number of steps ≤ number of words (or numbers) to be placed. Elements between two positions = (larger position − smaller position − 1).
Do not assume that five words mean five steps. When the last one or two elements are already in their correct places, the machine stops early. Also, if an element is already in its spot, that step only moves the other element.

Quick check

Same rule as the worked example (next word alphabetically from the left, next smallest number from the right). Input: 44 kiwi 19 fig 73 date. What is Step I?

Critical reasoning: think like a careful bank manager

Critical reasoning gives a short statement, notice or argument and asks you to judge it. The golden rule: use only what is written plus plain common sense. Do not bring in outside facts, and be suspicious of options with extreme words like all, every, always and never.

TypeWhat it asksQuick test
AssumptionWhat the writer takes for grantedNegate it: does the statement fall apart?
Strengthen / WeakenWhat makes the argument stronger or weakerDoes it rule out or offer another cause?
InferenceWhat must be true from the dataCan you prove it using only the passage?
Course of actionWhat should be done nextIs it practical and does it reduce the problem?
Cause and effectHow two events are linkedDoes one lead to the other, or does a third event explain both?

Assumptions: the negation test

Worked example: an online account advert

Statement: A bank advertises, 'Open a savings account online in just 10 minutes.'

Possible assumption: Some people want to open an account quickly.

Negate it: 'Nobody cares how fast an account opens.' Then the advert's selling point is pointless. So this IS assumed.

Possible assumption: Every Indian has a smartphone.

Too strong ('every'). The advert only needs some people to be online. NOT assumed.

Strengthen and weaken: hunt for the other cause

Worked example: a coaching institute's claim

Argument: A coaching institute in Patna says its new crash course raised its pass rate from 40% to 60% this year.

Weakener: This year's paper was easier, and institutes without a crash course also saw pass rates rise by about the same amount. (Another cause explains the rise.)

Strengthener: Among this year's students, those who skipped the crash course still passed at about 40%. (The other cause is ruled out.)

Irrelevant: The crash course is taught in Hindi and English.

Inference, course of action and cause-effect

  • Inference: it must be definitely true from the passage. If 60% of loans went to one group, 'more than half went to that group' follows; 'that group will always repay' does not.
  • Watch weighted averages: 60% of loans at 97% repayment and 40% at 88% gives 0.6 × 97 + 0.4 × 88 = 93.4% overall, not 97%.
  • Course of action: it follows only if it is practical, matches the size of the problem and actually helps. Four skimmed ATMs in Siliguri call for checking local ATMs, not shutting every ATM in India.
  • Cause and effect: ask whether one event can really produce the other, or whether a third event (like a cyclone warning) explains both.

Worked example: cause and effect

I. Onion prices in Kolkata markets nearly doubled this month.

II. Heavy unseasonal rain damaged onion crops in Maharashtra last month.

Damaged crops mean less supply, and less supply pushes prices up.

II happened first and leads to I.

Answer: II is the cause and I is its effect.

In course-of-action questions, extreme actions (ban it, shut everything, punish everyone) usually do not follow. In inference questions, an option that is only possibly true is still wrong. You need 'definitely true'.

Quick check

Statement: 'Pay your electricity bill through our bank's app and get ₹20 cashback.' Which of the following is assumed?

A simple time plan for Mains

Start with the short questions: a data sufficiency set or a few critical reasoning questions usually take about a minute each. Then take the input-output set, where one careful pass through all the steps answers several questions together. Keep the long puzzles for when you have a clear block of time.

  • DS: check I alone, then II alone, then together. A sure No counts as sufficient.
  • A chain of only ≥ and = never proves a strict >.
  • Input-output: read the last step first, then confirm the rule step by step.
  • Elements between two positions = larger − smaller − 1.
  • The machine can finish early; do not equate steps with the number of words.
  • Critical reasoning: use only the passage, apply the negation test, and avoid extreme options.

Ready to test yourself?

Lock it in with the practice test for this chapter.

Take the practice test

Keep studying

See all Banking (IBPS / SBI) study material →