UPSC Civil Services · Reasoning & Aptitude · Question 49 of 80

UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT (GS Paper 2), Question 49: answer and solution

Questions: official paperAnswers: official keyExplanations: AI-assisted, checked by How we checkReport a mistake

A mobile phone has been stolen. There are 3 suspects P, Q and R. They were questioned knowing that only one of them is guilty. Their responses are as follows : P : I did not steal. Q stole it. Q : R did not steal. I did not steal. R : I did not steal. I do not know who did it. Who stole the mobile phone ?

  • AP
  • BQ
  • CR
  • DCannot be concluded

Correct answer: (D) Cannot be concluded

We are told only one person is guilty. We are not told that anyone tells the truth or lies, so test each case. If P is guilty: P's "I did not steal" is false, and Q's and R's statements are all true. No contradiction. If Q is guilty: P's statements are both true, Q's "I did not steal" is false, and R's are true. No contradiction. If R is guilty: R's "I did not steal", P's "Q stole it" and Q's "R did not steal" are false. Again no contradiction, because nothing says how many people lie. Every case is consistent, and no condition (such as "only one person lies") lets us rule any of them out. So the thief cannot be identified. Answer: (d) Cannot be concluded

Try the whole UPSC Prelims 2025 CSAT (GS Paper 2) paper as a timed test

80 questions, the real time limit, then a full debrief: your rank among PadhoDost students, mistake types and what to fix.

Start the timed test

More UPSC questions on Reasoning & Aptitude

All UPSC Reasoning & Aptitude questions, every year →