Class 12 (CBSE) · Economics

Comparative Development Experiences of India and its Neighbours

23 practice questions with full step-by-step solutions, quick revision notes — free, no sign-up.

Reviewed by (19 years teaching)Written with AI helpReport a mistake

This chapter has

8
easy
12
medium
3
hard

Comparative Development Experiences of India and its Neighbours — quick revision notes

India, Pakistan and China began their development journeys at about the same time with similar strategies: India and Pakistan as mixed economies, China as a centrally planned command economy after 1949. China moved through the Great Leap Forward, the commune system and the Cultural Revolution before starting market reforms in 1978. Pakistan reformed in 1988 and India in 1991. Comparing demographic, GDP, sectoral and human development indicators shows China clearly ahead, India in the middle and Pakistan generally behind, and each country's strategy explains these outcomes.
  • First Five-Year Plans: India 1951, China 1953, Pakistan 1956. Reforms: China 1978, Pakistan 1988, India 1991.
  • China: People's Republic set up in 1949; Great Leap Forward (1958) for mass industrialisation, including backyard furnaces; communes for collective farming; Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution (1966-76) under Mao.
  • Chinese reforms came in phases: first agriculture, foreign trade and investment, then industry. Dual pricing and Special Economic Zones (SEZs) were used to attract foreign investors.
  • Pakistan nationalised capital goods industries in the 1970s, then turned to denationalisation and the private sector in the late 1970s and 1980s. Its Green Revolution brought mechanisation.
  • Pakistan's growth was hard to sustain because of political instability, over-dependence on remittances and foreign aid, and volatile agriculture.
  • Demography: Pakistan has the highest population growth and fertility rate, China the lowest growth and the highest urbanisation, and India the highest density. China's one-child norm (late 1970s) will lead to an ageing population.
  • Sectors: China has the largest share of industry in GDP and the lowest share of workforce in agriculture. In India and Pakistan, services have grown fastest, while China moved from agriculture to manufacturing.
  • Human development: China leads, India comes next and Pakistan is lowest (HDI, life expectancy, infant mortality). NCERT adds that liberty indicators, such as democratic participation, also matter.
  • China's success rested on its pre-reform base: land reforms, education and health infrastructure, decentralised planning and small enterprises.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Getting the reform order wrong. China reformed first (1978), then Pakistan (1988), then India (1991).
  • Assuming China, as the most populous country, must also be the most densely populated. India's density is the highest because China's area is much larger.
  • Saying China's structural change went straight to services, as in India. China went through manufacturing.
  • Treating SEZs and dual pricing as Indian reforms in this chapter. In NCERT they are features of Chinese reform.
Exam tip: Learn the indicator tables by ranking (which country is highest or lowest) rather than exact numbers, because CBSE MCQs usually test comparisons. For appraisal questions, link China's growth to its pre-1978 groundwork.

Comparative Development Experiences of India and its Neighbours — solved practice questions

6 Class 12 Economics questions with step-by-step solutions. Attempt each, then reveal the answer.

These worked examples are not in the timed test, so you can study them first.

  1. Q1mediumReport

    Which is the correct chronological order in which the first Five-Year Plans were launched?

    • AIndia, China, Pakistan
    • BChina, India, Pakistan
    • CPakistan, India, China
    • DIndia, Pakistan, China
    Show answer & solution

    Correct answer: (A) India, China, Pakistan

    India launched its First Five-Year Plan in 1951, China in 1953 and Pakistan in 1956. So the order is India, China, Pakistan.
  2. Q2easyReport

    The People's Republic of China was established, under one-party rule, in the year:

    • A1947
    • B1958
    • C1953
    • D1949
    Show answer & solution

    Correct answer: (D) 1949

    After the communist revolution, the People's Republic of China was established in 1949 under one-party rule. All critical sectors of the economy were then brought under government ownership and control.
  3. Q3easyReport

    The Great Leap Forward campaign, launched in China in 1958, mainly aimed at:

    • Aprivatising state-owned enterprises
    • Bopening China to foreign direct investment
    • Cindustrialising the country on a massive scale
    • Dcontrolling population through a one-child norm
    Show answer & solution

    Correct answer: (C) industrialising the country on a massive scale

    The Great Leap Forward (1958) aimed at industrialising China on a massive scale. People were even encouraged to set up industries in their backyards, and communes were introduced in rural areas.
  4. Q4easyReport

    Under the commune system introduced in rural China, people:

    • Aleased land to foreign companies
    • Bcultivated land individually and sold all output in the open market
    • Ccollectively cultivated land
    • Dworked only in Special Economic Zones
    Show answer & solution

    Correct answer: (C) collectively cultivated land

    Under the commune system, introduced during the Great Leap Forward, people cultivated land collectively. Individual farming came back only with the post-1978 reforms, when commune land was divided into small plots.
  5. Q5mediumReport

    During the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution (1966-76) in China:

    • Adual pricing was introduced in industry
    • BSpecial Economic Zones were set up to attract foreign investors
    • Cthe commune system was abolished
    • Dstudents and professionals were sent to work in and learn from the countryside
    Show answer & solution

    Correct answer: (D) students and professionals were sent to work in and learn from the countryside

    Mao introduced the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution (1966-76), under which students and professionals were sent to work in and learn from the countryside. SEZs, dual pricing and dismantling of communes all belong to the post-1978 reform period.
  6. Q6easyReport

    In which order did China, Pakistan and India begin their economic reforms?

    • AIndia (1978), China (1988), Pakistan (1991)
    • BChina (1978), Pakistan (1988), India (1991)
    • CChina (1988), India (1991), Pakistan (1978)
    • DPakistan (1978), India (1988), China (1991)
    Show answer & solution

    Correct answer: (B) China (1978), Pakistan (1988), India (1991)

    China began its economic reforms in 1978, Pakistan in 1988 and India in 1991. China was therefore the first of the three to introduce market-oriented reforms.

Ready to test yourself? Take the 17-question Comparative Development Experiences of India and its Neighbours test →